
Ask any couple who does most of the work at home, and you’ll often get two answers that add up to more than a whole.
This isn’t a joke about marriage. It’s a finding. In 1979 two psychologists, Michael Ross and Fiore Sicoly, asked married people in Canada to estimate their own share of various household jobs. When they added each couple’s estimates together, the total usually came to more than a hundred per cent. People claimed more than their share not only of the good things but of the bad ones too, such as starting arguments.
The reason isn’t vanity. You remember your own efforts in detail, because you were there for every one of them. You see only part of your partner’s. Your ledger is written in full colour; theirs is in faded pencil. Later work added a twist: people overclaim mainly on the jobs they do often, and tend to underclaim on the rare ones. The original sample was small, 37 couples, so take the exact numbers lightly. The mechanism is easy enough to check at home.
Now add the jobs that leave no trace. The sociologist Allison Daminger interviewed 35 couples about what she called the cognitive dimension of household labour: anticipating what’s needed, working out the options, deciding, and checking that it got done. In most of the mixed-sex couples she spoke to, the woman did more of it, especially the anticipating and the checking. Decisions were shared roughly equally. The thinking around them was not.
Anticipating and checking are almost perfectly invisible. When someone remembers that a child’s shoe size changed in August, nothing happens that anyone could see. When someone puts the bins out, there are bins on the pavement. And it cuts both ways: eleven hours at work and an hour on the road leave no trace in the kitchen either, except a tired person on the sofa.
The rule most couples live by says this shouldn’t matter: when you love someone, you don’t keep score. The rule has a point. The psychologists Margaret Clark and Judson Mills found that paying back a favour promptly made people like each other more when they expected a business-like relationship, and less when they expected a close one. Invoice every cup of tea and a partnership turns into a small company with two staff and a terrible atmosphere.
But there’s a difference between counting favours and looking at the load. The first is mean. The second is just accurate. And the rule against counting has a side effect nobody mentions: once the private counting starts, and it often does, the rule doesn’t stop it. It just stops the numbers being read out. Each ledger stays secret, and each one, thanks to Ross and Sicoly, shows its owner in credit.
If you want to try something, try this. Separately, each of you write down everything it takes to keep your shared life running, paid work and travel included. Put in the thinking jobs: remembering, planning, noticing, checking. Don’t estimate percentages; just list. Then swap, read the other list without comment, and mark anything on it you didn’t know was a job.
Expect both lists to be longer than you thought. That isn’t a failure. It’s the first accurate picture either of you has had.
When you say we don’t keep score, it’s worth asking which of two things you mean: I don’t need anything back, or I’d rather not find out.
This note comes from Chapter 7 of Nobody Signed This, where the rule goes on trial in full.
Sources. Michael Ross and Fiore Sicoly, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 37 (1979) [source]. Justin Kruger and Kenneth Savitsky, Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes 108 (2009) [source]. Allison Daminger, American Sociological Review 84 (2019): 70 interviews with 35 couples; in 26 of the 32 mixed-sex couples the woman did more of the cognitive work [source]. Margaret Clark and Judson Mills, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 37 (1979), experiments with students [source]. The distinction between counting favours and looking at the load is this note’s interpretation.