Sambor Kane

Take the treasure. Leave the dogma.

Love Is Not a Mind-Reading Test

A crystal ball on a wooden stand in a stone niche.

There’s a sentence that has ended more good evenings than alcohol: If you loved me, you’d know.

It sounds like a statement about love. It’s really a statement about telepathy, and the evidence on telepathy is not encouraging.

The psychologist William Ickes spent years measuring what he called empathic accuracy: how well one person can tell what another is thinking and feeling at a given moment. He would record two people talking, then sit each of them down with the tape, ask them to note what they had actually been thinking at various points, and then ask them to guess what the other person had been thinking at theirs. Close friends got it right somewhere between 30 and 40 per cent of the time. Strangers did markedly worse.

So knowing someone helps. It just doesn’t help enough to pass an exam. And if you loved me, you’d know is an exam, with no syllabus and a pass mark of a hundred.

Time doesn’t necessarily improve the score. In a 1997 study of 74 married couples, the ones who had been married for less time read each other more accurately, not less. My guess, and it’s only a guess, is that years together build confidence faster than they build accuracy. You stop checking because you think you know. Most of us drive the same way.

The belief itself seems to cost something. In 1982 two psychologists put together a questionnaire of beliefs that make relationships harder, and one of them was called, plainly, mindreading is expected: a partner should know what you think and feel without being told. More recent work at the University of Manitoba suggests what happens next. In one small study, people who held the belief and imagined being misunderstood were quicker to put it down to a lack of love. In a later study of 142 couples, the more one partner expected to be read, the lower both of them rated the relationship. Both were unpublished theses, and the first used imagined scenes rather than real arguments, so treat them as a hint rather than a verdict. But the hint is consistent. The misunderstanding happens to everyone. The belief turns it into evidence.

There’s a distinction hiding in here that’s worth keeping. Noticing that someone is upset and knowing what they need are two different skills. Plenty of people are good at the first. You come home with a face, and they see it at once. What they can’t see is whether you want questions or quiet, company or space, soup or a conversation. The rule treats noticing and knowing as one thing, and then marks the other person down for failing at the half nobody can do by looking.

The usual objection is that care you have to ask for doesn’t count. Asked-for comfort feels second-best. I understand the feeling, and I don’t think it survives a closer look. Asking doesn’t make care worth less. It gives the other person the one thing they can’t get by watching you: information.

So here’s a small, unromantic suggestion. On a calm day, not a bad one, tell the person you live with one sentence about what helps when you come home like that. Ask me twice. Leave me alone for an hour, then bring tea. Don’t fix it, just listen. One sentence. Then see what happens on the next bad day, and adjust.

Nobody signed a contract that says love includes telepathy. Most of us enforce it anyway.

This note comes from Chapter 1 of Nobody Signed This, where the rule goes on trial in full.

Sources. William Ickes, Everyday Mind Reading (2003), and Linda Stinson and William Ickes, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 62 (1992) [source]; the 30–40 per cent figure is from Ickes’s entry “Empathic Accuracy and Inaccuracy” in Encyclopedia of Human Relationships (2009) [source]. Geoff Thomas, Garth Fletcher and Craig Lange, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 72 (1997) [source]. Roy Eidelson and Norman Epstein, Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 50 (1982) [source]. Justine MacLean, MA thesis (2016), and Justine MacLean Legge, PhD thesis (2022), University of Manitoba [source]. That years together build confidence faster than accuracy is this note’s interpretation.


← All notes

← Wszystkie notatki